Seeing Supporting Stars

Not as long a list of actors to consider. Same rules apply as before, but these are primarily supporting actors.

1. Phillip Seymour Hoffman
2. Benicio Del Toro
3. Vince Vaughn
4. Paul Bettany
5. Don Cheadle
6. Joaquin Phoenix
7. Mark Ruffalo
8. Peter Sarsgaard
9. John C. Reilly
10. Jeremy Piven

Close:
Giovanni Ribisi
Owen Wilson
Ben Stiller
Greg Kinnear
Vincent Cassel
Jason Statham

Considered:
Luke Wilson
Wes Bentley
Sean William Scott

I'm sure I'm missing a ton more on this list. I'll revise if anyone comes up with anything in comments.